Technology Snapshot & Benefits:
Geothermal heating systems, also known as geo-exchange, ground source pumps, or
earth-coupled pumps, take advantage of the earth's nearly constant temperature
(45-75 degrees Fahrenheit, depending on latitude) to heat and cool buildings.
They work by pumping water and antifreeze or a refrigerant under the ground to
be heated or cooled by the earth and then pumped back through piping in the
house. In the winter, the earth is used as a heat source, and in the summer as a
heat sink. These systems are effective in any climate. The systems pollute less
than traditional fuel-burning systems and are about three times more efficient.
They are also more efficient than air-to-air exchange heating/cooling systems
because water can transfer a greater amount of heat than air. They also have a
longer lifetime than either system because almost all system components are
indoors or underground. The average lifetime is 25 years for outdoor components
and 50 years for parts that are installed indoors or underground.
Geothermal systems reduce the probability of a fire or carbon monoxide leak in a
home because they do not require any combustion. Another huge benefit is the
reduction of pollution. According to the Geothermal Heat Pump Consortium,
geothermal systems reduce CO2 emissions by about 1.1 million metric tons over 20
years, which is "the equivalent of converting about 58,700 cars to zero-emission
vehicles, or planting more than 120,000 acres of trees." Geothermal systems have
the EPA ENERGY STAR® label, which not only indicates that using these systems
benefits the health of our planet, but also that there may be incentives
associated with installing the system, such as tax benefits or lower mortgages.
Geothermal systems are also better at controlling relative humidity in buildings
compared with other systems.
There are two different types of geothermal heating and cooling systems:
open-loop and closed-loop. Open-loops systems require a body of water, and work
by pumping water from this source through the house and then back into the body
of water. In closed-loop systems, closed-loop piping through which water flows
is buried under the ground. The piping for closed-loop systems may be installed
vertically or horizontally, with vertical piping requiring a deep but thin
trench and horizontal piping requiring a wide but shallow trench.
Geothermal systems are very popular among people who have used them. In fact,
the California Energy Commission's Consumer Energy Center reports that 95
percent of people who have installed these systems would recommend them to
Estimated Cost Savings:
Geothermal heating systems can save between 30 and 70 percent on heating and
cooling costs compared to traditional fuel-burning systems, and are estimated to
use an average of 25 to 50 percent less electricity. These systems are often
able to generate excess heat in the summer or even the winter, and a device
called a desuperheater can use this excess heat from the system's compressor to
heat water at no additional cost. These systems are expensive to install,
costing about $2,500 per metric ton of unit, which works out to about $7,500 for
the average-sized American home. This is nearly double the price of installing a
traditional air conditioning unit. Closed-loop systems require an additional
cost for drilling the trench in which the piping is laid, which can cost $10,000
to $30,000, although the costs of installation have decreased in recent years
and are expected to continue falling. Overall, the long-term monetary benefits
of transitioning to a geothermal system outweigh the initial cost. The U.S.
Department of Energy estimates that the installation costs will pay for
themselves in five to ten years, and then building owners will actually profit
from the system for the remainder of the system's life. Schools and businesses,
which will probably be using the system for a long time, could take special
advantage of this profit to purchase new school or business necessities.
Besides saving money on monthly energy bills, geothermal heating systems are
usually more durable and require fewer maintenance and repair costs compared
with other units. Having a geothermal system adds value to a property
proportional to how much monthly energy bills are reduced. Some states also
offer monetary incentives for installing these systems.
Property owners who want some of the benefits of a geothermal system but simply
cannot afford installation can consider an air-geothermal hybrid system, called
a dual-source system. These systems are less efficient than a pure geothermal
heating and cooling system, but more efficient than a pure air-based or
fuel-based system. Also, dual-source systems are cheaper to install than pure
It is very important to get a qualified contractor to look at the building and
land around the building to determine the best kind of geothermal system to
maximize comfort, efficiency, and savings. All systems should be customized to a
particular situation. It is very important to make sure the contractor is
knowledgeable and qualified.
Open-loop systems are initially cheaper to install because they do not usually
require drilling; however, it is important to note that these systems work only
where there is a sufficient amount of fresh, relatively clean water available.
If this is the case and an open-loop system may be used, you must research local
regulations on discharging water and make sure these regulations are met.
Geothermal heating systems work in all climates, even extreme ones. Good
contractors should be able to give advice on specific regional issues that
affect drilling and installation, for example, very hard ground.
Installation and installation costs of geothermal systems vary, depending on the
type of system installed and the availability of a water source. All
installations, however, involve installing some type of piping and units for
converting and distributing heat. The ductwork used in these systems is the same
as that used for traditional systems, so no change is required during
installation. The most important thing about installation is finding a good
More Information On This Topic:
Heating/Cooling Systems" - Residential Environmental Design
"Geothermal Heat Pumps" - U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Efficiency and
Geothermal Heat Pump
"Geothermal or Ground Source Heat Pumps" - California Energy Commission,
Consumer Energy Center